Good to know
Frequently asked questions
The short answers. The long ones are in the dining room.
What makes Sammy's different from other pizzerias in Niagara Falls?
Sammy's has been family owned and operated since 1962, three generations of the Musolino family. The recipes are the originals, the dough is made in our kitchen every day, and the Half Tray that founder Sammy Musolino created is still the pizza the neighborhood orders for family dinners, parties and game nights.
What is the Half Tray pizza?
Fifteen square-cut slices of our tray-style pizza, a Niagara Falls tradition. It feeds a family, a table of friends or a living room on game night, and it's a Western New York classic. A Full Tray is thirty slices.
Do you offer online ordering?
Do you deliver in Niagara Falls?
Yes. We deliver locally throughout Niagara Falls and the nearby neighborhoods, including LaSalle, Hyde Park, Niagara University, Lewiston, Wheatfield, Sanborn and Grand Island. Pizza, wings, pasta, subs and more.
What kinds of pizza do you make?
New York style pies, Niagara Falls style trays, Detroit style, Chicago deep dish, stuffed crust, gluten-free crusts, and more than twenty specialty pizzas, from the Old Fashioned to the 7-1-6.
What are the most popular items?
The Half Tray, the Old Fashioned pizza, Sammy's Original Buffalo Chicken Wing pizza, the 7-1-6 pizza, Buffalo wings, Beef on Weck, strombolis and calzones, pasta dinners, and the Steak & Cheese Sub.
Do you have gluten-free options?
Yes. Choose a cauliflower crust (14") or a rice crust (12") for your pizza, or order the gluten-free pizza bowl, made with no crust at all.
Do you offer family meals and party trays?
Yes. Tray pizzas, wing combinations and large portions built for a group: family dinners, office lunches, birthdays and events. See the Catering & Events page for the banquet room and big orders.
Is Sammy's family owned?
Yes. Family owned and operated for more than sixty years, and run today by the third generation of the Musolino family.
Can we eat in?
Yes. There's a relaxed family dining room, and a bar with craft cocktails, beer and wine, and the game on.
Do you have a banquet room?
Yes. Our spacious banquet room hosts birthdays, graduations, business meetings, sports banquets and family gatherings. Send a note through the Catering & Events page, or call us to talk dates.
Where is Sammy's Pizzeria?
On Hyde Park Boulevard in Niagara Falls, New York, serving Niagara Falls, LaSalle, Niagara University, Hyde Park, Little Italy, North End LaSalle, Downtown Niagara Falls, East Side, Cayuga Island, Love Canal, Colonial Village, Lewiston, Wheatfield, Sanborn and Grand Island.